www.crexi.com - The Commercial Real Estate Exchange
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.

5819 CLEVELAND AVE Columbus OH 43231-2832

[Locked] • APN 010-104541

Upgrade  
to see sold price and date
Details
Property Type Retail
Sub Type Auto Shop
Building SqFt 6,844
Lot SqFt 42,131
Acreage ******
Sold Date ******
Sold Price ******
Sold Price/SqFt ******
Zoning Code CAC
Year Built 1997
Building Count 1
Opportunity Zone No
Lease Type ******
Remaining Term ******
Lease Expiration ******
Mortgage Amount ******

Property History

Intelligence Badge
Property Type
Property Type
Retail
Property Subtype
Auto Shop
Investment Highlights
  • FRESH 10-YEAR EARLY RENEWAL: In July 2024 the lease was amended to extend the term out to 10 Years through December 2034, communicating not only this locations strength but that this one is a keeper for Advance Auto Parts in spite of the record amount of announced store closures (15% of fleet). This is not surprising due to the store’s strong and stable 6.50% Rent to Sales ratio.

  • 25+ YEAR OPERATING HISTORY: This location has been in operation for over 25 years with a history of renewals, signaling the significant commitment AAP has made with this store as a flagship in the Columbus MSA.

  • PRICED BELOW REPLACEMENT COST: With the cost of construction rising rapidly, at just under $145 PSF there is significant value in this basis since comparable brand new construction Build-to-Suits have become prohibitively expensive, costing on average $250-325 PSF for merchant developers, driving rents for similar locations to be nearly $23.00 PSF or roughly $160,000-180,000 in basic rent before NNN expenses annually .

  • POWER-CENTER SHADOW ANCHORED: This Advance Auto Parts location is shadowed by the +250,000 SF Columbus Square Power Center which drives local retail traffic with synergistic tenants like Gordon Foods, Value Home Center and Dollar General.

  • COLUMBUS MARKET: Columbus is one of the fastest growing and affordable cities in the Midwest with strong employment and drivers such as the new $20B Intel semiconductor manufacturing facility being constructed in the New Albany submarket. Columbus is the home of The Ohio State University (OSU), serves as a major logistics hub nationally, and has been recognized for its business friendly policies among low taxes and incentives for entrepreneurship.

Property Type
Property Type
Retail
Asking Details
Asking Cap Rate
******
Marketing Description
Illuminate Real Estate is proud to present this seasoned, 6,844 square foot, freestanding Advance Auto Parts situated on .85 acres and located in Columbus, OH. The subject property was built in 1997 and currently boasts a 20+ year operating history at this location. This proven location benefits from a healthy occupancy cost (low rent to sales) and an established track record within the Advance store network. With approximately 4.75 years remaining on the most recent lease extension combined with multiple renewals over the life of the lease, this will showcase an operating history of just over 25 years. There are currently an additional (2) 5-year renewal options in place with 5% annual rental increases in each option. The lease is double-net in nature with the landlord maintaining responsibility for structural components of the building (including roof), pavement, sidewalks and 1/2 cost of major repair/replacement issues related to HVAC. The Tenant is responsible for taxes, insurance, CAM as well as all HVAC repairs up to $500 per occurrence.

The subject property has full access and excellent visibility to the nearly 25,000 vehicles that pass the store on Cleveland Ave. each day. The store’s strategic location places it at the epicenter of a critical population mass represented by an astounding 125,000 people within a 3 mile radius. While Cleveland Ave. is a major north/south arterial roadway connecting “the Outerbelt” (I-270) to downtown Columbus, the traffic along this section is not fleeting or transient. It is consistent, largely localized and can be directly attributed to the existing, value-oriented consumer base in the market. Cleveland Ave., intersects with State Highway 161 (E. Dublin Granville Rd.) just south of the subject property where there are combined daily traffic counts of 4 ~ 9,000. Immediate area retailers and economic drivers within a 1 mile radius of the site include: Home Depot, Walgreens, CVS, Chase Bank, Fifth Third Bank, Tim Horton’s, Fujiyama Japanese Steak House, Roosters, Columbus Square Shopping Center, Columbus Square Bowling Palace and Harbor Freight Tools to name a few. The “blue collar” demographic that comprises the makeup of the market is Advance Auto Parts’ ideal audience/customer. Average HH incomes within a 3 mile radius of the site exceed $62,000 annually.

Investment Highlights
  • Heavily localized traffic retail throughfare with over 24,904 vehicles per day
  • 20+ year operating history with low rent to sales
  • Strong tenant commitment to the site demonstrated by recent 5 year lease extension
  • Excellent density with 125,000+ population within a 3 mile radius
  • Pride of ownership/same owner since Advance Auto’s inception at location
  • Original 10 year NN lease has been renewed multiple times
  • E-Commerce resistant tenant with a strong and growing demand for aftermarket auto parts
  • Avergae HH income in excell of $62,000 within a 3 mile radius
  • Corporate quaranty from publicly traded investment grade tenant (”AAP”- NYSE: BBB-)
Sale Date
******
Sold Price
******
Buyer Borrower 1 Corp Indicator
******
Buyer Borrower 1 Name
******
Buyer Borrower 1 Relationship Type
******
Document Number
******
Document Type
******
Sales Price Code
******
Seller 1 Corp Indicator
******
Transaction Type
******
Seller 1 Name
******
Transfer Tax
******
Sold By
******
Sold To
******

Loan History

Intelligence Badge

Financial History

Intelligence Badge
****** Data
Net Operating Income
******
Reporting Date
******

Tax History

Intelligence Badge

Contact Information

Want to pull contact information for hundreds of properties at once? Try our new tool, Data Enrichment, and streamline your workflow. Try Data Enrichment Intelligence Badge
These phone numbers and email addresses are checked against the litigator and TCPA lists. Report an error

Ownership Information

Intelligence Badge

Zoning

Intelligence Badge
CAC SpecialCommunity Activity Center District
View municipality zoning documents
Upgrade to see the zone description and what's allowed on this property
Upgrade to search and view land use codes
Last updated Apr 15, 2026 For deeper zoning details, reports are available at Zoneomics

Property Details

Intelligence Badge

Contacts

Sold on
 BY:
JK
Jordan Kaufman PRO
•••.•••.6688
••••fman@••••••••••••••••••••.com
Brokerage logo
Listing removed on
 BY:
CS
Conrad Sarreal PRO
•••.•••.2847
••••••.•••real@••••••••.com
Brokerage logo
Listing removed on
 BY:
RF
Ryan Fitzgibbons
•••.•••.4468
••••.•••••••bons@••••••••.com
Brokerage logo
Listing removed on
 BY:
ST
Spencer Tyoran PRO
•••.•••.9756
•••••••.••oran@••••••••.com
Brokerage logo

Map

Comparable Properties

Intelligence Badge
*All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Does any data look off? Help us improve Crexi by offering your feedback!
For assistance, reach out to our support team at [email protected] or call 888.273.0423 . For press inquiries, contact [email protected]
Equal Housing Opportunity
5510 Lincoln Blvd #400, Los Angeles, CA 90094Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc.Crexi Technologies, LLCCXTechnology, LLC
© 2026 Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc. All Rights Reserved. DRE #02086591