Property History
Discover the unique charm of Admiral Peabody's Inn, a collection of six units nestled on the western shores of Seneca Lake. This laid-back resort offers a distinctive "home with a lake included" experience. This six-unit boutique motel on 0.77 acres consists of 6 units (comprised of 2 parcels) with 200 linear feet of lakefront on Seneca Lake. Quite a dead-end road, with municipal utilities for all 5 buildings - (One) 3 bedroom - 1.5 bath Unit, (Two) 2 bedroom - 1 bath Units, (Two) 1 bedroom - 1 bath Units. Wi-Fi extends throughout the property. Each unit features a deck with comfortable furniture and a gas grill, all with views of Seneca Lake. And the property has 10 off-street parking spaces and private lakefront docks for swimming, fishing, or simply enjoying the sun. Electric is available at the lakefront too! Expansion opportunity based on local code. Laundry facility on site for easy maintenance and office. Owner financing for qualified buyers. Extend the season with 3 insulated units.
- Unique Lakeside Setting: Six individual cottages with private decks and lake access on Seneca Lake, offering a distinctive guest experience.
- Strong Rental History: Admiral Peabody's Inn has a proven track record as a popular lodging choice in the Watkins Glen area, evidenced by positive guest reviews.
- Proximity to Key Attractions: Located less than a mile from downtown Watkins Glen and Watkins Glen State Park, and less than six miles from Watkins Glen International.
- Multiple Accommodation Types: Offers a diverse range of cottage sizes, catering to various group sizes and needs.
- Guest-Friendly Amenities: Includes private decks with grills, lake access with a dock, fire pit, Wi-Fi, and pet-friendly policies.
- Turnkey Operation: A fully operational and well-maintained property with a strong online presence.
- Value-Add Potential: Opportunity to further enhance revenue
- Accessible Transportation:
- Airports:
- Approximately 17.5 miles (around 25-30 minutes by car) to Elmira Corning Regional Airport (ELM)
- Roughly 29 miles (around 40-45 minutes by car) to Ithaca Tompkins International Airport (ITH).
- Major Cities:
- New York City: Approximately 254 miles, 4 hours and 20 minutes.
- Philadelphia: Approximately 261 miles, 4 hours and 15 minutes.
- Buffalo: Approximately 147 miles, 2 hours and 25 minutes.
- Rochester: Approximately 80 miles, 1 hour and 25 minutes.
- Airports:
Loan History
Financial History
Tax History
Contact Information
Ownership Information
Property Details
Contacts
Map
Comparable Properties
Does any data look off? Help us improve Crexi by offering your feedback!

































