2123 GREASY CREEK RD Nashville IN 47448-8708

With established infrastructure, flexible R2 zoning, and close proximity to downtown Nashville, this property presents a compelling opportunity to transform a long-standing community space into a purposeful investment.

Built and used for 50+ years as a church that recently relocated to a new facility, this charming building zoned as R2 (residential) sits in a peaceful, wooded setting and offers the perfect opportunity for a variety of commercial or residential uses. Built of Brown County stone, the property features an open and inviting main gathering area, high ceilings, and flexible interior space that can easily adapt to your vision-whether for continued use as a place of worship, a community center, studio, office, or conversion into residential living. Additional room include a large office area with built-in bookshelves, a kitchenette, two bathrooms, and storage rooms. All furnishings, appliances, and office equipment currently in the property will remain. There is a large paved lot that contains 29 designated parking spaces. With R2 zoning already established, this property allows for both residential and limited commercial applications, making it an ideal investment for those seeking versatility and potential in one location. Located less than 1.5 miles from downtown Nashville and surrounded by the natural beauty of Brown County, this property blends function, character, and opportunity in a setting that inspires creativity and purpose. The property currently has a tax exemption as a church.

Flexible Zoning (R2)

Allows for residential use along with select commercial applications—ideal for investors seeking multiple exit strategies or adaptive reuse.

Adaptive Reuse Opportunity

Purpose-built structure with over 50 years of use offers a solid foundation for conversion to residential living, office space, studio, or community-focused use.

Turnkey Potential

Includes existing furnishings, appliances, and office equipment—reducing upfront investment and allowing for immediate occupancy or phased improvements.

Distinctive Construction

Built with locally sourced Brown County stone, offering long-term durability and character that stands out in the market.

Functional Layout

Open main gathering space with high ceilings, plus private office, kitchenette, restrooms, and storage—easily reconfigured to suit a variety of uses.

Ample Parking

29-space paved lot supports higher occupancy uses such as events, office, or multi-unit conversion.

Proximity to Downtown Nashville

Located less than 1.5 miles from downtown, providing convenient access while maintaining a quiet, wooded setting.

Established Use & Infrastructure

Previously operated as a church, offering existing systems and layout suited for assembly, group use, or repurposing.

Tax Consideration

Currently tax-exempt; future tax obligations will be reassessed based on buyer’s intended use.