533 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Alex Hirsch

PRO

Charles Hirsch

PRO

Listed by Milbrook Properties Ltd

$29 - $35/SF/YR

1481 days on market

Updated 2 days ago

Bay Shore Commons

Building Details

Property Type

Retail

Sub Type

retail, shopping center

Tenancy

Multiple

Lease Type

NNN

Total Building SqFt

109,295

Vacant SqFt

471

Total Parking Spaces

471

Year Built

1951

Spaces

Available now: ground-floor end-cap retail space offering excellent storefront window visibility and convenient on-site parking just steps away. The space features 1,800 SF available, equipped with central A/C and heating, along with private restrooms. Previously occupied by a Huntington Learning Center, the layout is well suited for a variety of retail, educational, or service-oriented uses. Located adjacent to Miracle-Ear, providing strong neighboring synergy.

Elevate your brand in this 1,500 SF retail space—available Jan 2026! Formerly AT&T, it offers top signage on the façade and pylon. Join Supercuts and Jersey Mike’s in a busy center with strong foot traffic. Fully built with AC, heating, and private restrooms. Ideal for a new launch or expansion, this turnkey space is move-in ready. Don’t miss this prime retail opportunity in a high-visibility location!

Retail | 2 spaces available | 1,500 SqFt - 1,800 SqFt

Building description

Bay Shore Commons is a grocery-anchored shopping center with 24 stores and over 109,000 square feet GLA. Fronting the highly traveled Montauk Highway, the center is one of the dominant retail destinations in Islip and Suffolk County, NY. There are more than 233,000 living within a 5-mile radius of the center. National and regional tenants in the center include Stop & Shop, Retro Fitness, Bagel Boss, Tropical Smoothie, Club Pilates, Hand & Stone Spa, Chase, Dunkin Donuts, and European Wax Center. The property is professionally managed and maintained by a team with over 85 years of experience.

Building highlights

Corner Lot
Pylon Sign
Restaurants
Signage
Tenant Controlled HVAC
Recessed Lighting
Heavy Daytime Foot Traffic
Multi-Cultural Restaurants
Within minutes drive from Sunrise Highway
Abundant parking
Property is professionally maintained and managed
Property at a signalized intersection

Listing Contacts

Alex Hirsch

PRO

Charles Hirsch

PRO

Listed by Milbrook Properties Ltd

Map

Property History

Upgrade to Intelligence

Similar Properties

View All

*All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Lessee to verify all information.
Is there information that looks off?