205 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461

Matthews Real Estate Investment Services is proud to present Wantage Plaza & CubeSmart (managed).

Call for Offers Deadline 3/13/26

WANTAGE PLAZA & CUBESMART (managed)

205 NJ-23 | Wantage, NJ 07461

Click here to view the Property Video

https://vimeo.com/1134749567?utm_medium=email&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-9Iu4HnfVh81H43Rcatc5oPrmUJiezLnUwj_eLBnAIZrJ8tYBL0SRSaRWZvZJUTHHTQ8G4FdE00q0wNgtJquiD69iC2uA&_hsmi=402961648&utm_content=402961648&utm_source=hs_email

Investment Highlights:

• Listing Price: Market Bid

• ±13 Acres

• ±116,450 GSF Retail & Self Storage

• In-Place NOI: $718,414 (as of 12/31/25)

• Stabilized NOI: $1,287,681

• 51.9% Expense Ratio

Self-Storage Highlights:

• ±60,922 NRSF of Climate Control Self Storage Managed by CubeSmart

• 108 Exterior Boat and RV Parking Spaces in Fully Secured Lot

• ±67.4% Physical Occupancy & +-70% SF Occupancy as of 12/31/25

• +-50% Economic Occupancy as of 12/31/25

• Phase I Opened 10/1/2023

• Recently Added 58 CC Units in Phase III on 9/1/2025

• Phase II Added 29 CC Units Online 12/1/2025

Retail Center Highlights:

• ±34,292 SF of Retail

• 10 Suites

• 100% Leased

• 19 Years Average Occupancy

• Long-Term AT&T Cell Tower

• Below Market Rents | $11.84 PSF Avg.