5th and Pennsylvania Rare Corner Assemblage
Just Listed – Rare San Diego Infill Residential Development Site | Landmark Corner Between Bankers
Marketing description
Located at the northwest corner of Fifth Avenue and Pennsylvania Avenue, the subject property sits along the defining corridor between Hillcrest and Bankers Hill—two of Uptown San Diego’s most established and supply-constrained neighborhoods. Positioned within one of Central San Diego’s highest-rent districts, the area is characterized by strong housing demand, an affluent renter profile, and enduring barriers to new development. The offering comprises four contiguous parcels totaling approximately 0.62± acres (26,933 SF), positioned on Fifth Avenue’s primary retail spine and immediately adjacent to Balboa Park. Located within a designated Transit Priority Area just two miles north of Downtown San Diego, the site offers exceptional connectivity and long-term redevelopment appeal.
Fifth Avenue functions as the physical and economic link between Hillcrest’s vibrant retail environment and Bankers Hill’s refined residential character. The property benefits from direct frontage along one of the city’s most active pedestrian corridors, with seamless access to SR-163, Interstate 8, and Downtown. Strong renter demand is supported by limited development capacity, walkability, and a dense concentration of neighborhood-serving amenities, cultural institutions, and employment centers.
Zoned CC-3-10 (Community Commercial), the site participates in the Complete Communities Housing Solutions Overlay (Tier 2), allowing a maximum FAR of up to 8.0 and materially increased residential density. The recently approved Hillcrest Focused Plan Amendment, coupled with broader state-level housing incentives, further enhances the feasibility of high-density, transit-oriented infill development along this corridor.
The property is additionally supported by significant institutional investment, including the ongoing expansion of the UC San Diego Health – Hillcrest Medical Campus. In 2025, the system delivered the McGrath Outpatient Pavilion, a six-story, approximately 250,000-square-foot facility located less than one mile from the site. Together with Scripps Mercy Hospital, these institutions anchor a substantial healthcare employment base that continues to drive residential demand throughout Hillcrest, Bankers Hill, and the broader Uptown submarket.
Collectively, the site’s corner assemblage, by-right entitlement pathway, density upside, and irreplaceable Fifth Avenue positioning present a compelling opportunity to deliver a high-density residential or mixed-use project at the intersection of Hillcrest’s energy and Bankers Hill’s long-term residential stability.
Investment highlights
THE LINK BETWEEN BANKERS HILL & HILLCREST
Positioned at 3730 Fifth Avenue, the Property occupies a rare crossover location — just two blocks from Bankers Hill while firmly within the heart of Hillcrest. This unique positioning captures the luxury rent profile and residential appeal of Bankers Hill alongside Hillcrest’s walkable dining, retail, and cultural energy.
By bridging two of San Diego’s most desirable urban neighborhoods, the Property benefits from expanded tenant demand, premium rent justification, and long-term rental resilience.
INFILL TRANSIT-ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT SITE
Located within a designated Transit Priority Area along the Hillcrest–Bankers Hill corridor, the site offers immediate access to SR-163 and Interstate 8, with Downtown San Diego approximately two miles south. Its central location provides efficient connectivity to the region’s primary employment hubs, coastal amenities, and cultural destinations.
PREMIER WALKABLE URBAN LOCATION
With a Walk Score of 96 (Walker’s Paradise), the property delivers true pedestrian access to Fifth Avenue’s retail spine linking Hillcrest and Bankers Hill. Residents benefit from immediate proximity to restaurants, grocery stores, cafés, nightlife, boutique retail, Balboa Park, and neighborhood-serving amenities within one of Uptown’s most established urban environments.
ADAPTIVE REUSE & CREATIVE REDEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL
Existing improvements provide optionality for adaptive reuse or phased redevelopment. Developers can capitalize on sustained foot traffic, limited competing supply, and strong residential demand while delivering a design-forward, transit-oriented project aligned with modern urban preferences.
ENTITLEMENT TAILWINDS: HIGH-DENSITY RESIDENTIAL UPSIDE
Recent zoning changes approved by the City of San Diego materially increased allowable residential density in Hillcrest, reducing the minimum lot area per dwelling unit from 400 SF to 200 SF. The policy framework is projected to accommodate up to 17,000 additional housing units by 2050, reinforcing long-term redevelopment feasibility and value creation.
COMPLETE COMMUNITIES HOUSING SOLUTIONS OVERLAY (TIER 2)
The site participates in the Complete Communities Housing Solutions Overlay (Tier 2), allowing a maximum FAR of up to 8.0—supporting high-density residential or mixed-use development within a supply-constrained infill corridor.
RENT RESILIENCE & INVESTOR DEPTH
The Hillcrest–Bankers Hill corridor benefits from central positioning, exceptional walkability, and proximity to major medical and Downtown employment centers. These durable demand drivers have historically supported strong rent growth, stable occupancy, and consistent investor interest across market cycles within one of San Diego’s most supply-constrained urban submarkets.
CENTRAL ACCESS TO SAN DIEGO’S EMPLOYMENT BASE
The site offers efficient access to Downtown San Diego, Mission Valley (home to more than 7 million square feet of office space) less than three miles north, and the UTC / Sorrento Valley corridor, the region’s leading concentration of biotech and life-sciences employers.
STRONG DEMOGRAPHIC PROFILE
Approximately 236,000 residents live within a three-mile radius, with an average household income exceeding $127,000. Nearly half of the population is under age 35, supporting sustained demand from young professionals and renters seeking walkable, amenity-rich urban living.
Listing Contacts
Valuation Calculator
Valuation Metrics
Map
Broker Selected Comps View More Comps
Property History
Tax History
Similar Properties
Additional Information
Is there information that looks off?
