www.crexi.com - The Commercial Real Estate Exchange
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
31270018
31270019

3691 Windward Way, Columbus, OH 43204

CC
OH 2019002920
Colliers - Columbus, Ohio
MS
OH OH 2025004007
Colliers - Columbus, Ohio
MA
OH Auctioneer License No. 2019000050
Colliers - Cleveland, Ohio
Listed by Colliers - Columbus, Ohio, Colliers - Cleveland, Ohio
Unpriced
76 days on market
Updated 1 day ago

Pine Crossing Apartments

Details
APN 560-115541 & 570-115777
Property Type Multifamily
Sub Type Apartment Building
Net Rentable (SqFt) 162,816
Units 192
Occupancy 75%
Class C
Year Built 1972
Buildings 8
Stories 3
Acreage 12.310
Parking Spaces 325 spaces
Investment Type Value Add
Occupancy Date 03/06/2026
Ground Lease No

Multifamily | 192 Units

Marketing description

Colliers is pleased to present Pine Crossing Apartments on behalf of receivership. Strategically

positioned with convenient access to major transportation corridors, including I-70 and I-270, Pine

Crossing offers seamless connectivity to Downtown Columbus, The Ohio State University, and major

employment hubs. Visibility is paramount to capturing potential renter demand, and Pine Crossing’s

frontage along Wilson Road will forever organically capture significant attention. Pine Crossing was

built in 1972 and consists of 192 total units. Its desirable unit mix and strategic location within the

reputable Hilliard School District creates a rare opportunity to acquire institutional-quality workforce

housing in the Columbus MSA.

Currently 75% occupied, new ownership has the immediate ability to renovate units efficiently and restabilize

the property to achieve significant rental premiums. The property consists of 8 3-story gardenstyle

buildings with ample green space for potential amenity enhancements. The property recently

completed it’s final year of it’s decontrol period and now operates as a 100% Market-Rate multifamily

property, unencumbered by any restrictive covenants. Unit mix at the property consists of 14% onebedrooms,

73% two-bedrooms, and 13% three-bedrooms. On-site amenities include a clubhouse, fitness

center, swimming pool, picnic area, community gardens and laundry facilities.

New ownership has the potential to benefit from the ensuing market-rate operations after the

expiration of the LURA in 2023, and exciting potential to capture significant renter demand. Robust

renter demand is driven by 52 million square feet of Industrial space within a 5-mile radius from the

property and its commutable highway access.

Hilliard is one of Columbus’ most exciting submarkets for economic development with premier

accessibility. The City of Hilliard is advancing several transformative economic development

initiatives, including the AWS Hilliard Campus, Logistix Hub, Hilliard City Lab, and Truepointe

that will deliver over 5 million square feet of high-tech manufacturing, new office space, and luxury

apartment buildings. Nearby, Ohio State’s new Wexner Medical Center Tower, Ohio Health’s

Riverside Women’s Health Hospital and Downtown Trauma Hospital, and Nationwide Children’s

Main Hospital Expansion will have meaningful impacts on high-quality workforce housing demand

drivers. Residents also enjoy close proximity to Raymond Memorial Golf Course, the Scioto River,

Quarry Trails Metro Park, and many more recreational destinations within a short commute.

Investment highlights

Institutional Quality Workforce Housing

Well located workforce housing continues to see outsized demand as renters prioritize affordability, proximity to

jobs, and everyday livability in supply constrained submarkets. That durable demand is attracting highly favorable

mission rich financing, creating a powerful tailwind for capital seeking stable, socially impactful multifamily

investments.

Competitive Set Demonstrates Path To Value Add

Pine Crossing offers a clear, highly defensible path to value add, evidenced by Hilliard Village Apartments across

the street, currently achieving approximately $147 per month in rent premiums over Pine Crossing.

Immediate Proximity To Major Employment Hubs

Pine Crossing benefits from immediate access to over 52 Million Square Feet of Industrial Warehouse and

Manufacturing space within a 5-mile radius, creating robust demand for well-located workforce housing. The

Property is strategically positioned at the intersection of I-70 & I-270 along Wilson Road, providing the most

efficient commute times to major employment centers such as Bridge Park, Downtown Columbus, and The Ohio

State University.

Renowned Hilliard School District

Hilliard City Schools are known for strong academic performance, broad extracurricular offerings, and a culture of

high expectations that consistently attracts families to the area. The positive reputation supports long-term housing

demand and reinforces Hilliard’s position as one of Central Ohio’s most desirable school districts.

Additional Revenue Streams & Operational Efficiencies

New Ownership can implement additional revenue streams on trade outs and renewals for Bulk WiFi/Cable,

valet trash services and community fees to drive effective gross revenue. Pine Crossing’s operating expense ratio is

significantly higher than the market expectations of 45% of EGR. New Ownership has the potential to restructure

property insurance, reduce on-site personnel, bring expense reimbursements for water/sewer in line with market

expectations, and burn off elevated utility usage due to recent vacancy upticks. Modernizing Pine Crossing’s

digital marketing presence and implementing industry standard property management software will capture

robust renter demand and streamline operations swiftly.

Columbus, OH, A Roaring Economic Hub

The region is experiencing transformative growth driven by major public and private sector investment. Columbus

benefits from a diversified economy anchored by education, healthcare, technology, and advanced manufacturing.

The 2025 Global Groundwork Index by Site Selection Magazine ranked Columbus as the No.1 MSA for

Infrastructure Investment. In addition, Site Selection’s 2024 Governor’s Cup ranked Ohio as No.3 for total economic

development projects and economic development projects per capita.

Listing Contacts

CC
OH 2019002920
Colliers - Columbus, Ohio
MS
OH OH 2025004007
Colliers - Columbus, Ohio
MA
OH Auctioneer License No. 2019000050
Colliers - Cleveland, Ohio
Listed by Colliers - Columbus, Ohio, Colliers - Cleveland, Ohio

Valuation Calculator

Login or Sign up to see Valuation Metrics
Sign up for Crexi to see valuation metrics for this property
$
$
%
Loan Amount
$--
Annual Debt Service
$--
$--
Annual Cash Flow
$--
$--

Valuation Metrics

0
DSCR
--
Cap Rate
--
ROI

Map

Broker Selected Comps View More Comps

Property History

Intelligence Badge

Similar Properties

View All

Additional Information

Name
Cody J. Carey
License
2019002920
Brokerage
Colliers
Title
Vice President
Name
Mack Schlembach
License
OH 2025004007
Brokerage Phone
6144369800
Title
Associate
*All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyer to verify all information.
Is there information that looks off?
For assistance, reach out to our support team at [email protected] or call 888.273.0423 . For press inquiries, contact [email protected]
Equal Housing Opportunity
5510 Lincoln Blvd #400, Los Angeles, CA 90094Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc.Crexi Technologies, LLCCXTechnology, LLC
© 2026 Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc. All Rights Reserved. DRE #02086591