218 South Clay Street, Louisville, KY 40202 For Sale

Introducing The Holy Goat--a rare, design-forward hospitality asset in the heart of Louisville's vibrant NULU district. Originally constructed in 1843 as a church, this landmark property has been thoughtfully transformed into a fully turnkey, five-unit short-term rental experience that seamlessly blends historic architecture with elevated, modern design. Each suite is intentionally curated with its own identity and aesthetic--from the expansive three-bedroom, two-bath Fellowship Hall to a collection of one-bedroom and studio offerings--creating a layered guest experience that drives both demand and repeat stays. The interiors are striking, distinctive, and purpose-built to stand out in a crowded short-term rental landscape. Positioned just steps from NULU's award-winning restaurants, boutiques, and galleries, the location is as compelling as the asset itself. Additionally, the opportunity to expand to seven total units provides meaningful upside for increased revenue and scale. This is more than an income-producing property--it is a statement asset. A true trophy acquisition for the investor seeking a one-of-a-kind, high-performing addition to their portfolio. The Holy Goat is being listed by Hoagland Commercial in conjunction with Lenihan Sotheby’s.