www.crexi.com - The Commercial Real Estate Exchange
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
31693188
31693225

15760 Old State Rd 4a, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042

LS
FL BK3226537
The Agency Florida Keys
Listed by The Agency Florida Keys
$19,750,000
49 days on market
Updated 17 days ago

15760 Old State Rd 4A SUGARLOAF KEY

Details
Property Type Multifamily
Sub Type Single Family Rental Portfolio
Square Footage 4,402
Net Rentable (SqFt) 4,402
Units 2
Year Built 1996 and 1976
Buildings 2
Stories 2
Acreage 5.330
Zoning SRL
Investment Type Owner/User

Multifamily | 2 Single Family Detached Homes | Nightly Vacation Rentals - 500FT Rare Sandy Beach

Marketing description

Rare Private Sandy Beach - Oceanfront Estate with endless open ocean views, just 30 minutes to Key West! This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own over 5 acres of sprawling oceanfrontage on exclusive Sugarloaf Beach, with over 500 feet of pristine sandy shoreline. Zoned Sub Urban Residential, this rare estate offers unmatched potential--create a private luxury compound, a boutique resort rental, or VIP luxury retreat. One of the few properties in the Lower Keys where lucrative nightly rentals are allowed with Special Vacation Rental Permits, this remarkable estate provides exceptional flexibility with ample room to expand. This estate has two existing Single Family Residences - the main house has 4 bedrooms 4 bathrooms and the second house has 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and 1 half bath. Currently set up as two luxury nightly vacation rental homes! New 430-foot dock with stainless steel pilings, stainless steel support beams and composite decking. The 5-foot draft welcomes larger boats! Arrange private charter pick ups at the dock for your guests. Enjoy world-class boating, fishing and diving on your doorstep. American Shoal Lighthouse is only 5 miles directly in front of this spectacular property. Located on highly desirable Lower Sugarloaf Key in the Lower Keys, only 30 minutes to Key West, this hidden sanctuary is an unmatched offering for a discerning buyer seeking privacy, scale, and fantastic re-development potential. Nothing comparable exists in the area! Sugarloaf Beach remains one of the most coveted and rare stretches of beachfront in the Florida Keys. Whether you envision a secluded tropical retreat, a boutique luxury rental, or a visionary new oceanfront compound, this property is incredible with amazing potential to redefine with your personal touch. Opportunities like this come once in a lifetime. Take your private tour today and unlock the full potential of this iconic oceanfront estate!

Investment highlights

5+ Acre Oceanfront Estate | 500+ ft private sandy beach—rare scale in the Florida Keys

Prime Sugarloaf Beach Location | One of the most coveted & limited sandy shorelines

Zoned Sub Urban Residential (SR) | Flexible use: private compound, luxury retreat, or boutique rental

Nightly Rental Potential | Eligible for Special Vacation Rental Permits (rare in Lower Keys)

Existing Income | Two residences (4BR/4BA + 2BR/2.5BA) operating as luxury rentals

Redevelopment Upside | Significant acreage for expansion or repositioning

430’ Deep-Water Dock | ~5’ draft, new construction—ideal for larger vessels & charters

Premier Boating Access | World-class fishing/diving; American Shoal Lighthouse nearby

30 Min to Key West | Privacy with access to dining, marina & private aviation

Irreplaceable Trophy Asset | Scale, beachfront & zoning rarely found in one offering

Listing Contacts

LS
FL BK3226537
The Agency Florida Keys
Listed by The Agency Florida Keys

Valuation Calculator

Login or Sign up to see Valuation Metrics
Sign up for Crexi to see valuation metrics for this property
$
$
%
Loan Amount
$0.00
Annual Debt Service
$--
$--
Annual Cash Flow
$--
$--

Valuation Metrics

0
DSCR
--
Cap Rate
--
ROI

Map

Broker Selected Comps View More Comps

Property History

Intelligence Badge

Tax History

Intelligence Badge

Similar Properties

View All

Additional Information

Name
Lisa Swanson
License
BK3226537
Brokerage
The Agency Florida Keys
Brokerage Phone
(305) 924-3777
Title
Principal Broker
Brokerage Address
422 Fleming Street
*All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyer to verify all information.
Is there information that looks off?
For assistance, reach out to our support team at [email protected] or call 888.273.0423 . For press inquiries, contact [email protected]
Equal Housing Opportunity
5510 Lincoln Blvd #400, Los Angeles, CA 90094Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc.Crexi Technologies, LLCCXTechnology, LLC
© 2026 Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc. All Rights Reserved. DRE #02086591