www.crexi.com - The Commercial Real Estate Exchange
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
32630656
32630655

2 Locations

SD
NY NY 10401366519
Compass
Compass Real Estate
JS
NY 10401279108
Compass Real Estate
Listed by Compass, Compass Real Estate
$13,750,000
26 days on market
Updated 10 days ago

3 & 11 Madison St, Sag Harbor, New York

Details
APN 903-3-4-7
Property Type Retail, Mixed Use
Sub Type Retail
Square Footage 9,032
Beds 9
Tenancy Multi
Buildings 2
Acreage 0.365
Ground Lease No

Sag Harbor Village Assemblage - Two Adjacent Mixed-Use Buildings

Marketing description

3 & 11 MADISON ST, SAG HARBOR, NY

Assemblage of Two Mixed-Use Buildings in a Prime Village Location

3 Madison St, Sag Harbor Village - 6 bd 4 ba 4,468sf with a Retail Store & 2 Outbuildings Rare opportunity to purchase a historic building in the heart of Sag Harbor. This 4,468sf building is located at the crossroads of Madison Street and Main Street overlooking the Civil War Monument in the commercial section of the Historic District. The mixed-use building consists of prime retail space on the ground level as well as two 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom on the second and third floors. In addition, there are two detached outbuildings totaling 1,364sf.

Interior finishes feature custom moldings and wood beams, European high end finishes throughout. Large rear patio may be used for outdoor seating. Zoning allows for many possible uses including professional office, retail, gallery, design studio or restaurant/bed and breakfast.

11 Madison St, Sag Harbor Village - 3 bd 2 ba 3,307sf with a Retail Store

The " Sea Chest " building at 11 Madison is now for sale. This historic property of 3,307sf has a ground floor retail space and 2 separate apartments above.

The ground level storefront has charming detail, extensive natural light, & an open retail floor with exposed beams. The front patio adds additional interest attracting patrons into the store. The first floor apartment has 2 bedrooms, a living room with gas fireplace, a dining room, a kitchen, 1 bathroom and a nice patio overlooking a bucolic backyard. The second floor apartment is a 1 bedroom with a kitchen and 1 bath. Completely renovated. Private parking area.

Asking Price – $13,750,000

Inquire with the Hamptons Commercial RE Team for additional information.

Investment highlights

  • Historic buildings in the heart of Sag Harbor Village
  • Located at the crossroads of Madison Street and Main Street
  • Prime retail space on ground level
  • Custom moldings and wood beams, European high end finishes
  • Large rear patio may be used for outdoor seating
  • Zoning allows for professional office, retail, gallery, design studio or restaurant/bed and breakfast
  • Completely renovated
  • Private parking area

Listing Contacts

SD
NY NY 10401366519
Compass
Compass Real Estate
JS
NY 10401279108
Compass Real Estate
Listed by Compass, Compass Real Estate

Valuation Calculator

Login or Sign up to see Valuation Metrics
Sign up for Crexi to see valuation metrics for this property
$
$
%
Loan Amount
$0.00
Annual Debt Service
$--
$--
Annual Cash Flow
$--
$--

Valuation Metrics

0
DSCR
--
Cap Rate
--
ROI

Map

Broker Selected Comps View More Comps

Property History

Intelligence Badge

Similar Properties

View All

Additional Information

Name
Sean Deery
License
NY 10401366519
*All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyer to verify all information.
Is there information that looks off?
For assistance, reach out to our support team at [email protected] or call 888.273.0423 . For press inquiries, contact [email protected]
Equal Housing Opportunity
5510 Lincoln Blvd #400, Los Angeles, CA 90094Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc.Crexi Technologies, LLCCXTechnology, LLC
© 2026 Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc. All Rights Reserved. DRE #02086591