

Theodore Plaza
Grocery-Anchored Retail Strip | 8.49% Cap, 95.7% Leased | Signalized Corner, Crest Hill IL
Marketing description
Ellsbury Group is pleased to present Theodore Plaza, a 15,000 SF grocery-anchored multi-tenant retail center in Crest Hill, Illinois. Offered at $1,939,000 - an 8.49% in-place cap rate rising to 9.24% upon lease-up of the final 634 SF suite, roughly $130 per square foot and below replacement cost. The center is approximately 95.7% leased to five established, necessity-based tenants: anchor Carniceria Flores (grocery and meat market), My Waffle family restaurant, Marchelloni's Pizza, Estillo's Hair Salon, and AXO Brands apparel printing. In-place NOI is $164,670, increasing to a stabilized $179,070 on lease-up of the one remaining suite. Positioned at the NWC of Theodore Street and Raynor Avenue with ~23,000 vehicles per day, pylon signage and more than 50 surface parking spaces, the property draws from a dense, growing infill trade area - Crest Hill's population is up 51.7% since 2000, minutes from I-80, US-30 and IL-53. A stable, well-located retail investment with a defined value-add path. Offered as-is; certified rent roll and income/expense statement available upon request.
Investment highlights
- Signalized hard-corner location. NWC of Theodore St & Raynor Ave with ±23,000 vehicles per day, pylon signage and ~45 ft of glass line on the end cap.
- Stabilized income with light lease-up upside. Five established tenants in place (~95.7% leased); a single 634 SF suite remains to lease, adding NOI and taking the yield to a 9.24% stabilized basis.
- Internet- & recession-resistant tenancy. Grocery/meat market, two restaurants, salon and apparel printing — necessity and service retail insulated from e-commerce.
- Grocery-anchored daily-needs traffic. Carniceria Flores serves a dense, growing trade area (~19–24% Hispanic) where the format enjoys strong, durable demand.
- Attractive going-in yield. 8.49% in-place rising to 9.24% on lease-up.
- Clear value-add path. Modified-gross leases (landlord covers only shell, roof and structure) offer mark-to-market, expense recovery on renewal and the near-term 634 SF lease-up.
- Growing infill market. Crest Hill population is up +51.7% since 2000, within the Chicago MSA (~9.5M) and minutes from I-80, US-30 and IL-53.
Listing Contacts


Valuation Calculator
Valuation Metrics
Map
Broker Selected Comps View More Comps
Property History
Similar Properties
Is there information that looks off?




























