www.crexi.com - The Commercial Real Estate Exchange
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
Subscribe to Intelligence for full access
Analyze more property details including ownership and financial history. Share advanced property insights with your clients and teams.
34301615
34329644

2045 Ocean Boulevard, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509

PM
NY 10301224844
Horvath & Tremblay
MS
NY 1040130946
Horvath & Tremblay
Listed by Horvath & Tremblay
$29,900,000
1 day on market
Updated 1 day ago

Catalina Beach Club

Details
Property Type Hospitality, Business for Sale
Sub Type Hotel, Business and Building
Square Footage 77,400
Units 343
Year Built 1938
Stories 2
Acreage 6.470
Zoning MR, R-CA
Investment Type Owner/User
Ground Lease No

Rare Private Beach Club and Real Estate Land | 343 Units | 6.47 AC

Marketing description

Horvath & Tremblay has been retained on an exclusive basis to arrange for the sale of the Catalina Beach Club in Atlantic Beach, New York. Catalina Beach Club is a premier private beach club situated on 6.47 acres across four parcels on the Atlantic Ocean in one of Long Island's most affluent and exclusive coastal communities. The Property features approximately 77,400 square feet of improvements and includes 343 membership units comprised of 73 Ocean View Cabanas, 108 Sand Court Cabanas, and 162 Bath Cabins, along with swimming pools, food and beverage facilities, recreational amenities, and expansive beachfront access. The Club has operated continuously under the current ownership family since 1944 and represents one of the most established private beach club properties on Long Island.

Catalina Beach Club occupies a highly desirable oceanfront location within the Village of Atlantic Beach, offering direct access to the Atlantic Ocean and convenient connectivity throughout Nassau County, Queens, and the greater New York metropolitan area. Located approximately 21 miles from Manhattan, the Property benefits from proximity to the Long Island Rail Road, Nassau Expressway, Meadowbrook State Parkway, and John F. Kennedy International Airport. The surrounding area is characterized by affluent residential communities, private beach clubs, marinas, golf courses, and a wide range of retail, dining, and recreational amenities. The Property's combination of stabilized operating income, irreplaceable oceanfront real estate, and future redevelopment optionality creates a unique investment opportunity in one of the New York metropolitan area's most supply-constrained waterfront markets.

ACCESS & CONNECTIVITY

Catalina Beach Club benefits from exceptional connectivity throughout Long Island and the greater New York metropolitan area. The Property is located just minutes from the Long Island Rail Road's Long Beach Station, providing direct service to Penn Station and Grand Central, while nearby Nassau Expressway, Loop Parkway, Meadowbrook State Parkway, and Southern State Parkway offer convenient access to Nassau County, Queens, Brooklyn, and Manhattan.

The Property is situated approximately 10 miles from John F. Kennedy International Airport, one of the nation's busiest international gateways, providing convenient access for seasonal residents, visitors, and business travelers. The surrounding roadway network also offers direct connections to major regional employment centers throughout Long Island and New York City.

Atlantic Beach's strategic South Shore location provides residents and visitors with the unique ability to enjoy a waterfront lifestyle while remaining within commuting distance of Manhattan, Downtown Brooklyn, Long Island City, and the region's major business districts.

AREA AMENITIES & DEMAND DRIVERS

Catalina Beach Club is located in Atlantic Beach, one of Long Island's most exclusive and supply-constrained coastal communities, benefiting from strong demand driven by affluent demographics, limited waterfront development opportunities, and its proximity to New York City. The Village has long been recognized as a premier seasonal and year-round destination for residents seeking a private beachfront lifestyle within the New York metropolitan area.

The Property is positioned near several of the region's largest employment centers, including Manhattan, Downtown Brooklyn, Long Island City, and JFK Airport, providing access to a diverse employment base spanning finance, healthcare, professional services, transportation, technology, and government sectors. Major employers throughout the region include JPMorgan Chase, Goldman Sachs, Citigroup, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, Mount Sinai Health System, Northwell Health, JetBlue Airways, and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.

Major attractions and recreational amenities nearby include the Long Beach Boardwalk, Atlantic Ocean beaches, Atlantic Beach Club, Silver Point County Park, numerous marinas and yacht clubs, and several premier private golf clubs throughout Nassau County. The Property also benefits from proximity to the retail, dining, and service corridors of Long Beach, Lawrence, Cedarhurst, Hewlett, and the broader Five Towns region.

STRONG MEMBERSHIP DEMOGRAPHICS & DEMAND

Catalina Beach Club benefits from strong incomes and a densely populated trade area. More than 120,900 people reside within 3 miles of the Property with an average household income exceeding $128,076, while more than 238,464 residents live within 5 miles with an average household income of more than $148,240.

The surrounding area features an extensive collection of waterfront dining destinations, upscale restaurants, and neighborhood establishments throughout Atlantic Beach, Long Beach, Lawrence, and Cedarhurst. Residents and visitors enjoy a diverse mix of local favorites, beachfront venues, casual dining concepts, and destination restaurants that serve the South Shore's affluent year-round and seasonal population.

Retail amenities throughout the surrounding trade area are anchored by a strong mix of national and regional retailers, grocery stores, pharmacies, and service providers. Nearby shopping destinations include the Five Towns retail corridor, Long Beach's central business district, and numerous neighborhood shopping centers featuring brands such as Stop & Shop, Trader Joe's, CVS, Walgreens, and Target.

The Property also benefits from close proximity to a wide range of recreational and lifestyle amenities, including private beaches, yacht clubs, marinas, waterfront parks, country clubs, golf courses, and the Long Beach Boardwalk. These amenities, combined with Atlantic Beach's affluent residential character and direct access to New York City, continue to reinforce the area's long-term desirability for residents, members, and visitors alike.

Investment highlights

■ Premier oceanfront private beach club situated on 6.47 acres in Atlantic Beach, NY

■ Long-standing family ownership with operating history dating back to 1944

■ 343 membership units consisting of Ocean View Cabanas, Sand Court Cabanas, and Bath Cabins

■ Strong in-place cash flow with demonstrated membership retention and recurring seasonal revenue

■ Significant value-add opportunity through expanded food & beverage, events, and hospitality programming

■ Irreplaceable beachfront location with direct Atlantic Ocean frontage

■ Multiple parcels with redevelopment and alternative-use optionality

■ Affluent Long Island demographic profile with strong barriers to entry and limited competing beachfront development opportunities

■ Convenient access to Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, JFK International Airport, and the broader New York metropolitan area

Listing Contacts

PM
NY 10301224844
Horvath & Tremblay
MS
NY 1040130946
Horvath & Tremblay
Listed by Horvath & Tremblay

Valuation Calculator

Login or Sign up to see Valuation Metrics
Sign up for Crexi to see valuation metrics for this property
$
$
%
Loan Amount
$0.00
Annual Debt Service
$--
$--
Annual Cash Flow
$--
$--

Valuation Metrics

0
DSCR
--
Cap Rate
--
ROI

Map

Broker Selected Comps View More Comps

Property History

Intelligence Badge

Similar Properties

View All

Additional Information

Name
Ethan Cole
License
10491208561
Title
Broker of Record
Name
Paul Massey
License
10301224844
Brokerage
Paul J. Massey, Jr.
Brokerage Phone
(212) 784-6760
Title
Managing Director
Name
Mendel Sears
License
1040130946
Brokerage
Horvath & Tremblay
Brokerage Phone
2124709151
Title
Senior Associate
Brokerage Address
485 Madison Avenue
*All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyer to verify all information.
Is there information that looks off?
For assistance, reach out to our support team at [email protected] or call 888.273.0423 . For press inquiries, contact [email protected]
Equal Housing Opportunity
5510 Lincoln Blvd #400, Los Angeles, CA 90094Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc.Crexi Technologies, LLCCXTechnology, LLC
© 2026 Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc. All Rights Reserved. DRE #02086591