
Listed by Coldwell Banker Commercial AMH
$4,500,000
907 East McCoy Blvd & 311 Wittig Road
Details
Property Type Retail
Sub Type Gas Station, Convenience Store
Square Footage 6,632
Pumps 16
Cap Rate 5.90%
NOI $265,636
Occupancy 100%
Tenancy Single
Year Built 2000
Year Renovated 2021
Buildings 2
Acreage 1.500
Zoning B-2
Ground Lease No
AMAZING TWO GAS STATION PORTFOLIO
Marketing description
Tomah Gas Station Portfolio | 907 East McCoy Blvd & 311 Wittig Road, Tomah, WI 54660
Rare opportunity to acquire a high-performing two-property gas station and convenience store portfolio in Tomah, Wisconsin, offered at an asking price of $4,500,000. This package includes two established locations with strong operating history, updated infrastructure, and consistent fuel volume.
907 East McCoy Blvd, Tomah, WI 54660 features a 3,163 SF c-store on a 41,818 SF lot, with a renovated roof (2020), four double-sided pumps replaced in 2022, and double-wall fiberglass tanks installed in 2000. The site pumps roughly 50,000 gallons monthly and reported $333,171 gross profit in 2025.
311 Wittig Road, Tomah, WI 54660 offers a 3,469 SF c-store on a 23,522 SF lot, with a renovated roof (2021), four double-sided pumps replaced in 2022, and double-wall fiberglass tanks installed in 2000. This location also pumps roughly 50,000 gallons monthly and generated $368,790 gross profit in 2025.
An exceptional chance to own two turnkey fuel and retail assets in a growing Wisconsin market.
Investment highlights
- C-Store at 907 East McCoy Blvd: 3,163 sq ft
- Lot Size at 907 East McCoy Blvd: 41,818 sq ft
- C-Store roof renovated in 2020 at 907 East McCoy Blvd
- 4 double-sided pumps replaced in 2022 at 907 East McCoy Blvd
- Double wall fiberglass tanks installed in 2000 at 907 East McCoy Blvd
- Roughly 50,000 gallons pumped monthly at 907 East McCoy Blvd
- $333,171 Gross Profit in 2025 at 907 East McCoy Blvd
- Annual taxes: $11,179 at 907 East McCoy Blvd
- C-Store at 311 Wittig Road: 3,469 sq ft
- Lot Size at 311 Wittig Road: 23,522 sq ft
- C-Store roof renovated in 2021 at 311 Wittig Road
- 4 double-sided pumps replaced in 2022 at 311 Wittig Road
- Double wall fiberglass tanks installed in 2000 at 311 Wittig Road
- Roughly 50,000 gallons pumped monthly at 311 Wittig Road
- $368,790 Gross Profit in 2025 at 311 Wittig Road
- Annual taxes: $9,004 at 311 Wittig Road
Listing Contacts

Listed by Coldwell Banker Commercial AMH
Valuation Calculator
Login or Sign up to see Valuation Metrics
Sign up for Crexi to see valuation metrics for this property
Loan Amount
$0.00
Annual Debt Service
$--
$--
Annual Cash Flow
$265,636.00
$22,136.33/mo
Valuation Metrics
0
DSCR
5.9%
Cap Rate
5.9%
ROI
Broker Selected Comps View More Comps
Property History
Tax History
Similar Properties
Is there information that looks off?










