www.crexi.com - The Commercial Real Estate Exchange
For Sale
Retail 

Sullivan County Retail Properties for Sale

43 results
Pictures of Mixed Use, Special Purpose, Retail, Industrial, Office, Land property located at E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$2,500,000
E Broadway
Mixed Use • 1,963,249 SqFt

E Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Retail, Office property located at 485 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$449,000
4 Unit Commercial
Retail • 8.80% CAP • 6,922 SqFt

485 Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Hospitality, Retail, Land property located at 7 Depot, Fremont, NY 12760 for sales - image #1
$1,300,000
Long Eddy Historic Catskills Commercial Opportunity
Historic Hotel, Saloon & General Store for Sale in Sullivan County, NY

7 Depot Fremont, NY 12760

Pictures of Retail, Business for Sale property located at 458 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$150,000
458 Broadway
Retail • 200,000 SqFt

458 Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Hospitality, Mixed Use, Retail property located at 708-720 Parksville Rd, Parksville, NY 12768 for sales - image #1
$799,000
708-720 Parksville Road, Parksville
I-86 Diner and House

708-720 Parksville Rd Parksville, NY 12768

Pictures of Industrial, Retail property located at 184 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
Opportunity Zone
$1,295,000
184 E Broadway
Industrial • 43,560 SqFt

184 E Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Retail property located at 951 Rt-17B, Bethel, NY 12720 for sales - image #1
$699,900
951 Rt-17B
Retail • 0.00% CAP • 3,871 SqFt

951 Rt-17B Bethel, NY 12720

Pictures of Retail, Office, Hospitality property located at 31 South Main Street, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$3,900,000
31 S Main Street Liberty Theatre
Historic Downtown Landmark Theatre Featuring Income-Producing Commercial Space

31 South Main Street Liberty, NY 12754

See New Listings First!
Save your filters and get alerts when new properties hit the market.
Save My Search
Pictures of Retail property located at 951 State Rt 17B, Bethel, NY 12720 for sales - image #1
Unpriced
951 State Route 17B,
Retail • 3,871 SF

951 State Rt 17B Bethel, NY 12720

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail, Office, Land property located at 79 Elk Point Road 83, Liberty, NY 12758 for sales - image #1
$799,995
79 Elk Point Road 83
Mixed Use

79 Elk Point Road 83 Liberty, NY 12758

Pictures of Retail, Land property located at 1 Depot Street, Fremont, NY 12760 for sales - image #1
$350,000
1 Depot Street
Retail

1 Depot Street Fremont, NY 12760

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 1908 Old Route 17, Rockland, NY 12776 for sales - image #1
$3,500,000
1908 Old Route 17
Famous Roscoe Diner - Roscoe, NY

1908 Old Route 17 Rockland, NY 12776

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 553 County Road 94, Hankins, NY 12741 for sales - image #1
$475,000
553 County Road 94
Live and work in one spot!

553 County Road 94 Hankins, NY 12741

Pictures of Mixed Use, Land, Retail property located at 1095 State Route 17B, Bethel, NY 12762 for sales - image #1
$825,000
1095 State Route 17B
Mixed Use • 2,904 SqFt

1095 State Route 17B Bethel, NY 12762

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 89 Sullivan Avenue, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$519,000
89 Sullivan Avenue
Business for Sale

89 Sullivan Avenue Liberty, NY 12754

Pictures of Industrial, Land, Mixed Use, Office, Retail property located at 740 Southwoods Dr, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
Unpriced
740 Southwoods Drive
Industrial

740 Southwoods Dr Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 41 Martin Ln, Mongaup Valley, NY 12762 for sales - image #1
$944,500
41 Martin Lane (Ross)
Mixed Use • 2,400 SqFt

41 Martin Ln Mongaup Valley, NY 12762

Pictures of Retail property located at 314 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$3,900,000
Sullivan County Prime Commercial Opportunity
Versatile 26,000+ SF commercial property in Monticello featuring expansive showroom, multiple wareho

314 E Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Retail, Mixed Use property located at 57 FORESTBURGH RD, MONTICELLO, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$400,000
Monticello Mixed-Use Opportunity
High-traffic Monticello site with turnkey income potential

57 FORESTBURGH RD MONTICELLO, NY 12701

Pictures of Land, Retail property located at State Route 97, Highland, NY 12719 for sales - image #1
$55,000
State Route 97
Land • 0.22 acres

State Route 97 Highland, NY 12719

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 314 E Broadway, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$3,900,000
314 E Broadway
Business for Sale

314 E Broadway Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Retail, Hospitality property located at 145 State Route 17B, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$325,000
145 State Route 17B
Retail

145 State Route 17B Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Retail property located at 28 Upper Main Street, Callicoon, NY 12723 for sales - image #1
$829,999
28 Upper Main Street
Retail

28 Upper Main Street Callicoon, NY 12723

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 301 N Main Street, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$1,150,000
301 N Main Street
Business for Sale • 5,020 SqFt

301 N Main Street Liberty, NY 12754

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at TBT Route 42, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$2,995,000
TBT Route 42
Mixed Use

TBT Route 42 Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 515 Broadway, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$789,000
515 Broadway
Business for Sale

515 Broadway Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 141 State Route 17B, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$150,000
141 State Route 17B
Business for Sale

141 State Route 17B Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 3 Hamilton Road, Burlingham, NY 12722 for sales - image #1
$495,000
3 Hamilton Road
Mixed Use • 1,190 SqFt

3 Hamilton Road Burlingham, NY 12722

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 553 County Road 94, Fremont, NY 12741 for sales - image #1
$599,000
553 County Road 94
Business for Sale • 4,440 SqFt

553 County Road 94 Fremont, NY 12741

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 139 Kirk, Narrowsburg, NY 12764 for sales - image #1
$99,000
139 Kirk
Business for Sale

139 Kirk Narrowsburg, NY 12764

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 57 Forestburgh Road, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$400,000
57 Forestburgh Road
Mixed Use

57 Forestburgh Road Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail, Hospitality property located at 36 Beaver Brook Road, Highland, NY 12792 for sales - image #1
$360,000
36 Beaver Brook Road
Mixed Use

36 Beaver Brook Road Highland, NY 12792

Pictures of Retail, Special Purpose, Office property located at 31 S Main Street, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$3,900,000
31 S Main Street
Retail

31 S Main Street Liberty, NY 12754

Pictures of Retail property located at 125 Jefferson Street, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$525,000
125
Retail

125 Jefferson Street Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Retail property located at 28 Raceway Rd, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$749,000
28 Raceway Road
This thriving Italian restaurant presents an exceptional turnkey opportunity in Monticello, NY.

28 Raceway Rd Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 47 Cooper Road, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$1,190,000
47 Cooper Road
Business for Sale • 6.00% CAP

47 Cooper Road Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Industrial, Mixed Use, Retail property located at 20 Creamery Road, Livingston Manor, NY 12758 for sales - image #1
$299,000
20 Creamery Road
Industrial

20 Creamery Road Livingston Manor, NY 12758

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 458 Broadway, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$150,000
458 Broadway
Business for Sale • 5,940 SqFt

458 Broadway Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 89 Beaver Brook Road, Eldred, NY 12764 for sales - image #1
$489,000
89 Beaver Brook Road
Mixed Use

89 Beaver Brook Road Eldred, NY 12764

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 1132 State Route 52, Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759 for sales - image #1
$799,000
1132 State Route 52
Business for Sale

1132 State Route 52 Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 85 Beaver Brook Road, Highland, NY 12764 for sales - image #1
$489,000
85 Beaver Brook Road
Mixed Use

85 Beaver Brook Road Highland, NY 12764

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 21 Edgar Street, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$315,000
21 Edgar Street
Mixed Use

21 Edgar Street Liberty, NY 12754

Pictures of Retail property located at 1759 State Route 209, Mamakating, NY 12790 for sales - image #1
$650,000
1755
Retail

1759 State Route 209 Mamakating, NY 12790

Results per page:
...... 1

Sullivan County, NY Retail Properties for Sale Market Overview

Search retail stores for sale in Sullivan County, NY and explore 44 shops for sale on Crexi’s marketplace. Currently, there are 2,327,331 square feet of retail property in Sullivan County, averaging $1,065,652 and representing $44,757,394 in total value. The average price per square foot for retail stores in Sullivan County is $88 with a median cap rate of 4%.



Crexi features Sullivan County auto shops for sale, quick service restaurants, Dollar Trees,Dollar Generals, and more that suit a variety of commercial real estate needs.

Nearby Retail Properties

Show Less

Sullivan County Property Types

Show Less
For assistance, reach out to our support team at [email protected] or call 888.273.0423 . For press inquiries, contact [email protected]
Equal Housing Opportunity
5510 Lincoln Blvd #400, Los Angeles, CA 90094Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc.Crexi Technologies, LLCCXTechnology, LLC
© 2026 Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc. All Rights Reserved. DRE #02086591