www.crexi.com - The Commercial Real Estate Exchange
For Sale
All Types 

Sullivan County Properties for Sale

233 results
Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at Lot  11.1 State Route 55 and Mail Road, Highland, NY 12719 for sales - image #1
$895,000
Lot 11.1 State Route 55 and Mail Road
Land • 77.89 acres

Lot 11.1 State Route 55 and Mail Road Highland, NY 12719

Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at California Avenue, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$250,000
California Avenue
Land • 10.81 acres

California Avenue Liberty, NY 12754

Pictures of Land property located at NYS Rt 17 and Old Rt 17, Harris, NY 12742 for sales - image #1
$499,000
NYS Rt 17 and Old Rt 17
Land • 21.92 acres

NYS Rt 17 and Old Rt 17 Harris, NY 12742

Pictures of Multifamily property located at 38 Edgar Street, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$499,000
38 Edgar Street
Multifamily • 5 Units

38 Edgar Street Liberty, NY 12754

Pictures of Land, Multifamily property located at 1315 Sackett Lake Rd, Forestburgh, NY 12777 for sales - image #1
$600,000
1315 Sackett Lake Rd
Land • 75.1 acres

1315 Sackett Lake Rd Forestburgh, NY 12777

Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at Lot 59.2 Lower Lumber Road, Lumberland, NY 12737 for sales - image #1
$39,000
Lot 59.2 Lower Lumber Road
Land • 3 SqFt

Lot 59.2 Lower Lumber Road Lumberland, NY 12737

Pictures of Land property located at 780 Tanzman Road, Liberty, NY 12768 for sales - image #1
$879,000
780 Tanzman Road
Land • 8 acres

780 Tanzman Road Liberty, NY 12768

Pictures of Land property located at 32 Jefferson St, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$4,000,000
32 Jefferson
Land • 3.5 acres

32 Jefferson St Monticello, NY 12701

See New Listings First!
Save your filters and get alerts when new properties hit the market.
Save My Search
Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at Polster, Callicoon, NY 12726 for sales - image #1
$75,000
Polster
Land • 7.97 acres

Polster Callicoon, NY 12726

Pictures of Land property located at 278 Ferndale Road, Ferndale, NY 12734 for sales - image #1
$300,000
TBD Ferndale Road
Land • 26.5 acres

278 Ferndale Road Ferndale, NY 12734

Pictures of Land property located at 22 State Route 52A, Kenoza Lake, NY 12750 for sales - image #1
$125,000
22 State Route 52A
Land • 15.3 acres

22 State Route 52A Kenoza Lake, NY 12750

Pictures of Hospitality property located at 392 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$4,295,000
Monticello - 48 Room Motel / NY Rt 17 Area
48 Room Motel / NY Rt 17 Area

392 Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Land property located at Hilltop Road, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$85,000
Hilltop Road
Land • 6 acres

Hilltop Road Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at Fourth Circle, Thompson, NY 12775 for sales - image #1
$12,000
Fourth Circle
Land • 0.262 acres

Fourth Circle Thompson, NY 12775

Pictures of Land property located at 1195 NYS Route 17B, Bethel, NY 12762 for sales - image #1
$349,900
1195 NYS Route 17B
Land • 30.9 acres

1195 NYS Route 17B Bethel, NY 12762

Pictures of Hospitality, Mixed Use, Retail property located at 708-720 Parksville Rd, Parksville, NY 12768 for sales - image #1
$799,000
708-720 Parksville Road, Parksville
I-86 Diner and House

708-720 Parksville Rd Parksville, NY 12768

Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at 208 Parksville Road, Parksville, NY 12768 for sales - image #1
$89,900
208 Parksville Road
Parksville partially improved property

208 Parksville Road Parksville, NY 12768

Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at Park Avenue, Mamakating, NY 12790 for sales - image #1
$6,000
Park Avenue
Hidden Gem Near Masten Lake – Unlock the Potential

Park Avenue Mamakating, NY 12790

Pictures of Land property located at TBD Bobwhite Trail, Bethel, NY 12762 for sales - image #1
$149,900
TBD Bobwhite Trail
Land • 20.47 acres

TBD Bobwhite Trail Bethel, NY 12762

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 41 Martin Ln, Mongaup Valley, NY 12762 for sales - image #1
$944,500
41 Martin Lane (Ross)
Mixed Use • 2,400 SqFt

41 Martin Ln Mongaup Valley, NY 12762

Pictures of Hospitality property located at 1166 Co Rd 114, Cochecton, NY 12726 for sales - image #1
$849,000
Unify Retreat
Hotel / Retreat - at a special location

1166 Co Rd 114 Cochecton, NY 12726

Pictures of Land property located at 2282 State Rt 17B, Bethel, NY 12720 for sales - image #1
$995,000
Self-Storage @ 2282 STATE ROUTE 17B COCHETON NY
Monticello Area Commercial Property

2282 State Rt 17B Bethel, NY 12720

Pictures of Land property located at Lot 41 Leers Road, Lumberland, NY 12737 for sales - image #1
$38,998
Lot 41 Leers Road
Land

Lot 41 Leers Road Lumberland, NY 12737

Pictures of Land property located at Lot 42 Leers Road, Lumberland, NY 12737 for sales - image #1
$39,000
Lot 42 Leers Road
Land

Lot 42 Leers Road Lumberland, NY 12737

Pictures of Land property located at 27 Woods Road, Highland, NY 12792 for sales - image #1
$175,000
27 Woods Road
Land

27 Woods Road Highland, NY 12792

Pictures of Land property located at 290 Cypert Road, Woodbourne, NY 12788 for sales - image #1
$250,000
290 Cypert Road
Land • 18.72 acres

290 Cypert Road Woodbourne, NY 12788

Pictures of Multifamily property located at 6696 Rt-52, Cochecton, NY 12726 for sales - image #1
$550,000
6696 Rt-52
Multifamily • 5 Units

6696 Rt-52 Cochecton, NY 12726

Pictures of Land property located at 269 State Rt 17B, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$649,900
269, 275 & 277 St. Rte. 17B
High Visibility on NYS Route 17B. Commercial/Industrial/Residential. Vacant

269 State Rt 17B Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Land property located at 42 Concord Road, Thompson, NY 12751 for sales - image #1
$150,000
42 Concord Road
Prime 2 acres in a high‑demand location, ideal for residential or commercial use.

42 Concord Road Thompson, NY 12751

Pictures of Office property located at 55 Sturgis Rd, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$1,925,000
REDUCED: Medical Office Building at 55 Sturgis, Monticello
Office • 9.64% CAP • 8,868 SqFt

55 Sturgis Rd Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Land property located at Lot 17.9 Shortcut Road, Cochecton, NY 12726 for sales - image #1
$399,900
Lot 17.9 Shortcut Road
Land • 56.58 acres

Lot 17.9 Shortcut Road Cochecton, NY 12726

Pictures of Multifamily property located at Henri Pl, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
virtual tour
$7,000,000
Monticello Cresent Luxury Townhomes
Fully Approved, Shovel-Ready project in Sullivan County. Rare rental opportunity

Henri Pl Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at Ski Run Road, Wurtsboro, NY 12790 for sales - image #1
$40,000
Ski Run Road
Unique Stream front property

Ski Run Road Wurtsboro, NY 12790

Pictures of Land, Special Purpose property located at Church aka Pan Am Road, Mountain Dale, NY 12763 for sales - image #1
$150,000
Church aka Pan Am Road
Mountaindale acrarage and camping

Church aka Pan Am Road Mountain Dale, NY 12763

Pictures of Land property located at 59 Lanahan Rd, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
Opportunity Zone
$950,000
59 Lanahan Road
Central to shopping district!

59 Lanahan Rd Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Retail, Office property located at 485 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$449,000
4 Unit Commercial
Retail • 8.80% CAP • 6,922 SqFt

485 Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 89 Sullivan Avenue, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$519,000
89 Sullivan Avenue
Business for Sale

89 Sullivan Avenue Liberty, NY 12754

Pictures of Land property located at 145 Miller Rd, Callicoon, NY 12723 for sales - image #1
$999,000
Catskills Mountains 110-Acre Horse Farm/Subdivision
Racehorse Rest Farm or Equestrian Center and Briddle Trails

145 Miller Rd Callicoon, NY 12723

Pictures of Industrial property located at 3508 Route 209, Wurtsboro, NY 12790 for sales - image #1
$875,000
STORAGE & DISTRIBUTION FACILITY
Industrial • 10,328 SqFt

3508 Route 209 Wurtsboro, NY 12790

Pictures of Land, Retail property located at State Route 97, Highland, NY 12719 for sales - image #1
$55,000
State Route 97
Land • 0.22 acres

State Route 97 Highland, NY 12719

Pictures of Land property located at Black Forest Road, Lumberland, NY 12737 for sales - image #1
$50,000
Black Forest Road
Land

Black Forest Road Lumberland, NY 12737

Pictures of Land property located at Highland Ave, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$199,999
Highland Avenue
Land • 4.9 acres

Highland Ave Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 89 Beaver Brook Road, Eldred, NY 12764 for sales - image #1
$489,000
89 Beaver Brook Road
Mixed Use

89 Beaver Brook Road Eldred, NY 12764

Pictures of Multifamily property located at 589-593 W Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$1,900,000
589-593 W Broadway
Multifamily • 6.00% CAP • 13 Units

589-593 W Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Multifamily property located at 16 Church Street, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$800,000
16 Church Street
Multifamily • 9.00% CAP • 8 Units

16 Church Street Liberty, NY 12754

Pictures of Business for Sale property located at 3 Hamilton Road, Bloomingburg, NY 12721 for sales - image #1
$495,000
3 Hamilton Road
Deli Business for sale

3 Hamilton Road Bloomingburg, NY 12721

Pictures of Multifamily property located at 457 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$2,999,950
457 Broadway
Multifamily • 24 Units

457 Broadway Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 85 Beaver Brook Road, Highland, NY 12764 for sales - image #1
$489,000
85 Beaver Brook Road
Mixed Use

85 Beaver Brook Road Highland, NY 12764

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 553 County Road 94, Fremont, NY 12741 for sales - image #1
$599,000
553 County Road 94
Business for Sale • 4,440 SqFt

553 County Road 94 Fremont, NY 12741

Pictures of Business for Sale, Retail property located at 47 Cooper Road, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$1,190,000
47 Cooper Road
Business for Sale • 6.00% CAP

47 Cooper Road Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Multifamily property located at 1189 State Route 52, Fallsburg, NY 12759 for sales - image #1
$875,000
1189 State Route 52
Multifamily • 8 Units

1189 State Route 52 Fallsburg, NY 12759

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at TBT Route 42, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$2,995,000
TBT Route 42
Mixed Use

TBT Route 42 Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Multifamily property located at 23 Crestwood Road, Cochecton, NY 12752 for sales - image #1
$1,100,000
23 Crestwood Road
Multifamily

23 Crestwood Road Cochecton, NY 12752

Pictures of Retail property located at 28 Raceway Rd, Monticello, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$749,000
28 Raceway Road
This thriving Italian restaurant presents an exceptional turnkey opportunity in Monticello, NY.

28 Raceway Rd Monticello, NY 12701

Pictures of Retail, Hospitality property located at 145 State Route 17B, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$325,000
145 State Route 17B
Retail

145 State Route 17B Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Mixed Use, Office, Land property located at 453 Broadway, Thompson, NY 12701 for sales - image #1
$445,000
453 Broadway
Mixed Use • 1,880 SqFt

453 Broadway Thompson, NY 12701

Pictures of Land property located at 64 Gale Road, Bethel, NY 12762 for sales - image #1
$2,300,000
64 Gale Road
Land • 65 acres

64 Gale Road Bethel, NY 12762

Pictures of Land, Multifamily property located at 122 Jaketown Road, Bethel, NY 12783 for sales - image #1
$3,699,999
122 Jaketown Road
Land • 172.2 acres

122 Jaketown Road Bethel, NY 12783

Pictures of Business for Sale, Mixed Use, Multifamily property located at 2-26 Hope-Street, Hurleyville, NY 12747 for sales - image #1
$1,545,000
Hurleyville Collection
Investment Offering: The Hurleyville Collection — Mixed‑Use & Multifamily Portfolio

2-26 Hope-Street Hurleyville, NY 12747

Pictures of Mixed Use, Retail property located at 21 Edgar Street, Liberty, NY 12754 for sales - image #1
$315,000
21 Edgar Street
Mixed Use

21 Edgar Street Liberty, NY 12754

Results per page:

Sullivan County, NY Properties for Sale Market Overview

Check out commercial properties for sale in Sullivan County, NY only on Crexi. Crexi features Sullivan County self storage for sale, land for sale, retail space for sale, offices, industrial properties, and more that suit a variety of commercial real estate needs.

Currently, there are 235 commercial real estate listings available in Sullivan County, representing $242,669,702 with an average price of $1,050,518. The average price per square foot in Sullivan County is $675 with a median cap rate of 7%

In Sullivan County, the average price for:

Industrial properties is $1,940,790

Retail properties is $1,065,652

Office properties is $2,167,893

Multifamily properties is $1,143,629

Nearby Properties

Show Less

Sullivan County Property Types

Show Less
For assistance, reach out to our support team at [email protected] or call 888.273.0423 . For press inquiries, contact [email protected]
Equal Housing Opportunity
5510 Lincoln Blvd #400, Los Angeles, CA 90094Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc.Crexi Technologies, LLCCXTechnology, LLC
© 2026 Commercial Real Estate Exchange, Inc. All Rights Reserved. DRE #02086591